Don’t be fooled by the excuses and high fives. The hits just keep on coming. And trust us, there’s more.

Well …

It seems the chairman of the Wayne County Board of Education is not too happy with us.

Chris West said he doesn’t read what we write. But boy, during and after Thursday’s school board meeting it sure seemed like he has — or someone else has and told him about it.

We don’t know if he is reading what you have been writing, either, but we suspect he has. You know, just a hunch.

But let’s, for the time being, take him at his word.

West was a little worried that we might twist what he said and report inaccurately any answers he gave to the questions we asked after Thursday’s BOE budget session.

So, while we stand by every bit of the reporting and commentary we have published so far — and would remind you and West that he has only granted us one interview since the WCPS debacle began the first week of June — we are going to be extra, extra careful about how we discuss what we asked him and his response.

So, let’s get started.

We asked West about why the board failed to act as a check on former Superintendent Dr. Michael Dunsmore — why board members were “shocked” to learn about a FOUR-YEAR financial nosedive.

Well, West wants you to know that the Board of Education has rules to follow — and that includes staying out of the day-to-day operation of the district. In fact, he said he and the other board members went to “training” to learn about those limits.

We assume that includes not meddling in things like, for example, whom the district hires and in what positions.

Oh, and stuff like budgets and spending, too.

In the interest of full disclosure, we admit, we have served on boards before, so we know that there are rules about messing around in the day-to-day operations of the organizations those boards oversee.

But the boards are charged with something else, too — helping to ensure the organization or entity they serve is financially healthy and adhering to the mission to which it has been tasked with accomplishing.

And that means keeping a close eye on the CEO, in this case, the superintendent, and the finances of the organization, in this case, the school district.

And yes, that applies to government entities, too. Just ask the Wayne County Board of Commissioners.

Oh wait. We did.

Commission Chairman Ray Mayo said the county’s financial health is Job 1, and he and his board ask a lot of questions, and they look at audits and financial statements.

In fact, as soon as audits are completed, a meeting is called between county leadership and the auditor to discuss the findings.

Maybe they had a different training session?

But West deserves the opportunity to explain the board’s role and why the district has gotten into the financial mess it has under his watch.

And since he didn’t do that at the end of Thursday’s session when given the chance — and instead used his time to laud the district’s pricey, out-of-town attorney — we gave him another shot after the meeting was adjourned.

Basically, he told us that the board was going to wait until all the information was out and then those findings would speak for themselves.

<Crickets>

Okkkaaayyy.

We also asked West why he took the time to commend Schwartz & Shaw for its legal representation and the firm’s “hard work” in the midst of public criticism over the $400,000+ price tag for nine months of work — a figure more than $125,000 more than the county paid for its three-person legal team during the same timeframe.

West said he could not comment on specific cases or billings — and he is right, he can’t as a party to the lawsuits as chairman of the board. But he did say that this is a different world and that the district has had to pay a lot of fees because of the number of cases and issues it had to deal with — some of which required state-level expertise.

We wanted to know why no local firm, which would have kept the money in the county, was hired.

Both West and vice chairman Jennifer Strickland, who happened to be in the area when this question was asked, said the board interviewed a number of firms, and that Schwartz & Shaw seemed to be the best fit.

He was worried about saying this, but West is right about one thing: You either pay at the beginning or pay at the end, which means a quality firm with good credentials saves you in court fees, etc. 

But here’s the thing.

Schwartz & Shaw specializes in education law, so calling in an expert for complex cases might be advisable. School boards do it all the time. 

Just ask Tyrell County Public Schools. You know, Dunsmore’s former district. Schwartz & Shaw represented that district’s Board of Education — and Dunsmore — in a defamation suit a few years back.

But $400,000+ in nine months when your financial house is crashing down? We’re not sure that is justifiable or fiscally responsible. 

And in the interest of transparency, we’ve talked to some attorneys. They were just as shocked as we were.

But we will wait to see the bills from April, May and June to see the whole picture. We know there was some pretty significant legal work happening during that timeframe, too. Our guess is that price tag is even higher. By a long shot.

Thursday’s meeting wasn’t all bad, though.

More than a couple of board members — specifically, Len Henderson, Patricia Burden and Ven Faulk — did not just sit there and take in the information Interim Superintendent Dr. James Merrill presented as gospel.

They asked questions. And Faulk was more than a little concerned about the implications of the findings so far — you know, that staff cuts and increased class sizes would be necessary to balance the budget — and what those cuts would do to the quality of education in this county.

Strickland spoke up, too.

She was still “mad” about the situation — and said increased class sizes could affect classroom management, and could prompt parents to send students to charter schools or Johnston County.

But like West, she failed to take even a little ownership of the lack of oversight that got WCPS to this point in the first place.

By the way, parents, students and WCPS employees are mad, too. Don’t believe us? You clearly haven’t been following this saga on social media.

But the difference between them and several longtime members of the board is that they know there is plenty of blame to go around.

In other words, they find it hard to believe that Dunsmore and former Finance Director Michael Hayes were the only ones who knew about the district’s impending financial doomsday.

And there was something else that happened that we found troubling, too.

There was a bunch of praising going on — for the Central Office staff who “have worked so hard” and who have put their heads together to solve the problems and to manage the potential fallout from the district’s staggering deficit.

But what we did not hear were any significant cuts in the Central Office portion of that budget — even though higher-than-recommended salaries in that very area were among the mentions in the most recent “mystery” audit that no one on the BOE seemed to know about.

We know what board members will say. More than $400,000 worth of cuts that will help balance the budget came from Central Office — or, as Merrill put it, “our own back yard.”

But reducing the amount of money spent on travel, training and supplies seems like a meager sacrifice when inside local schools, teachers and administrators are about to be asked to do a whole lot more with a whole lot less in the middle of a global pandemic.

And even though it looks like the budget includes cuts to contract services, there are still some big questions to be answered about that area and everything else that has been going on in WCPS as a $7 million fund balance became what is increasingly looking like an $8 million budget deficit when you consider that mystery $3 million fund transfer from the Food Service Fund.

That’s right. Merrill told the board that money had to be paid back. 

And don’t forget about the money borrowed from the state to make June payroll and fulfill the district’s commitment to pay teachers their stipends. That is “new debt,” too.

There are still so many issues to address here, but one that stands out is that once again, this county is relying on consultants and an outsider to fix the problem.

And by the way, we apparently have a new audit firm, too. Nice to know.

The bottom line is that no matter how you spin this, the people who will be paying for what has been what we can only characterize as a complete dumpster fire are the teachers and the students.

The district is promising to do everything it can to avoid cutting staff and class offerings. We suspect that there will be more than a couple board members who will have something to say about those decisions should they come up.

But keep in mind that this mess did not happen in one year — and it won’t be fixed in that amount of time either.

The judgment will come as we see how closely the board watches this latest crew of consultants — and the new interim superintendent — how insistent they are that they get information and what they do with it when they get it.

And more judgement will come at the ballot box for years to come, when voters decide whether or not they want to continue to support longtime board members who are, at best, completely clueless, or, at worst, complicit and negligent in a 4-year financial meltdown that Merrill acknowledged would forever change education in Wayne County.

Didn’t catch that part of the meeting? Merrill said once you cut staff — once you scale back to the state allotment level which he acknowledged was not good enough by most educators’ standards — it was hard to get those positions back.

So, there’s no way to sugarcoat it. We just walked up on the aftermath of a train wreck.

But for the board members who were in office when Dunsmore was hired — and those who voted for the extension of his contract (or, you know, decided not to vote and got counted as a “yes”) — to act like heroes because the fixers are washing away the carnage reeks of the same old political gymnastics we should be rejecting.

We would be more impressed if they just plain admitted they screwed this up — that they failed to place the check on Dunsmore and his cabinet they were elected to provide.

But, as West said, the findings will speak for themselves. 

And we have plenty more to show you.

So, get ready for another round of shock and awe in the coming days.

At this point, you know we will be watching carefully. And we know you will, too.

26 thoughts on “Don’t be fooled by the excuses and high fives. The hits just keep on coming. And trust us, there’s more.

  1. Ok, so all that being said, when does the state and the SBI get involved? The board has violated state open meetings law, and it is obvious there is a drastic monumental mis-approriation of funds (i.e, projects with no contracts) that have contributed to this dumpster fire of epic financial proportions. The board is complicit in some of this at the very least and with the overpayment of central office salaries, (as well as creative job creation for some) I am certain that the roots of this “conspiracy ” run deep. How do we as a county or even just as concerned citizens get more light shined on this from above and bring an end to the shady deals as well the cliques and old boy networks that abound throughout the wcps system? Trust me, there is alot more behind the scenes that has happened in years past that has been swept aside that folks know about, all people need to do is ask and dig just below the surface to find all the dirt and skeletons buried around that central office.

  2. Looks like the NON is banking on the same fear tactics used by an illicit president in riling up the masses of ignorant Conservatives that infect society in a daily basis.

    1. Who wants to tell this moron that Chris West and Jennifer Strickland are GOP who think COVID is a hoax and are supporters of that illicit president. They are in that group of ignorant conservatives you’re talking about. Sounds like a Democrat on the school board wrote this. Maybe one who is afraid of losing an election. Not sure Pat Burden knows how to use the internet though.

      1. Totally disagree. I don’t think it’s a Democrat. I would bet the farm this is West or Strickland because they are Trumpers. This is right up their alley. Follow the “discredit the media” book and continue to not take any ownership of this mess. Thank god for this paper. It’s about time we had some real journalists in Wayne County fighting for our kids.

    2. I am far from being a conservative by any means, but my job is now in danger. Hardly fearmongering; the people need to be informed so they make the right decision come election time. And maybe people need to be prepared and on our side when and if there is a strike.

    3. Ha!! That’s BS Mr. “Cant Scare Me.” Your comment makes no sense at all. This is fine reporting and research, something LONG OVERDUE in Wayne County.

      Chris West should also resign, and be held accountable. As the chair of the BOE, he represents their collective ineptitude. Hell, the ENTIRE board should go.

      Let’s replace them with ACTUAL EDUCATORS!

    4. HUH… Ms Burden, is that you??? What you said makes absolutely no sense. Deflecting is not going to work, this time.

      1. Please…Ms. Burden doesn’t have enough sense to type a paragraph on this platform. Do us a favor and not give her ANY credit for anything…Remember she is a long term board member. LOL

  3. Our leaders have failed us to because they refuse to accept responsibility for their mistakes. Think about that. This is a board of EDUCATION. What message does this send to our kids? Make a mistake and find someone else to blame it on. So glad somebody is watching these people again. Every other board in Wayne County needs the same treatment. This is our county. Let’s take it back.

  4. I am so sick about hearing this called a shortfall or a deficit. This is a theft. And yet – no forensic accountant has been hired, no mention of trying to track down where the money went!

    Also – where have Dunsmore and Hayes landed themselves?

  5. Wow.

    “We assume that includes not meddling in things like, for example, whom the district hires and in what positions.”

    She just called him out for bullying Dunsmore into hiring his son.

    WE SEE YOU, Rene, even if West “doesn’t read” what you write. Yeah right! LMFAO!

    1. Not only did West get jobs for his sons, Yes both of them, but also for several of his son’s friends. Making more money than veteran employees. It is time for accountability.

      Is Dunsmore’s wife still an WCPS employee?

  6. Mr. Hayes should be your next interview. Maybe he can shed some light on what happened since he appears to be being used as a scapegoat.

    1. I’m sure there will be no comments from Mr Hayes. You can be sure that those expensive attorneys made sure that he signed something that assured his silence.

  7. Dunsmore and West were buddies. Dunsmore scratched Chris West and Chris West scratched Dunsmore. They did more than break our district. They bullied a lot of people because they knew they could. Why? Because ALL board members allowed it. They knew what was going on and felled to act. Michael Hayes is a “scapegoat” for Dunsmore. He couldn’t hire, create positions, and increase salaries. He did not have that kind of power. It would be better if they would just admit they (the board) messed up. Chris West and other board members were involved in day-to-day operations. They and everyone else knows it. What they are doing now is simply lying to attempt to cover their tracks and save face. Whoever says that this is a scare tactic clearly is tired of The New Old North bringing things to the light. Also seems like whoever wrote that just wants this paper to go away. They say they are not scared but obviously they are. Their comment is an attempt to stop what is coming and to get readers to stop looking daily at this website. I get up and pour a cup a coffee and wait for the next thing to come up. Wayne County Public Schools is currently a freak show and everyone knows it. The only people that want admit it are the ones at the district office. They know they have been exposed and look incompetent. Every single one of them.

  8. People could loose their jobs, but, they aren’t telling who. How are these people supposed to make a living? Other counties are hiring NOW!! They are setting their employees up for financial ruin. You can bet your bottom dollar an outsider making the decision will not care. Maybe that is why they hired him.

    Time for an audit by law enforcement.

  9. I understand the need to find out who is to blame as well as being concerned over people losing their jobs. But I think everyone commenting here have forgotten what the School System is all about–our children!!

    Other school systems are trying to figure out how they are going to reopen schools in the fall, and more than likely that will include some form of remote learning so the School System will have to figure out how to provide the necessary equipment and internet services for students. These are the issues other school systems are talking about, yet Wayne County can’t have any of those conversations because we’re too far in debt to even begin to think about school reopening in the fall.

    Jennifer Strickland was correct–something needs to be done quickly or parents will move their kids to other counties or charter schools or homeschool. And when you lose students, you lose federal funding.

    1. Mrs. Strickland should have thought about that a long time ago. She is part of the problem and needs to go.

  10. The only people who forgot about the kids are the CO employees and the BOE. Not only were the children forgot about but hard working employees from each sector.

  11. Interesting that Shumate Faulk has an advertisement on this page …hope that’s not a conflict of interest for Mr Faulk, WCPS board member ….

    1. I’m all for going after WCPS but this comment is stupid. If you been reading this paper for more than just a day you would know Shumate Faulk has been on here since before New Old Nirth started blasting the school board. Its not a conflict of interest. If anything, it’s funny that a board member advertises with a paper that is investigating them. Sounds like Faulk is a smart businessman though. Everyone I know is reading these stories and he is getting a whole bunch of people seeing his advertisement. Maybe his opponent in the upcoming election wrote this. If it is him, he might want to be smart like Ven and get himself in front of all the people noticing.

    2. Yeah. This is a pretty weak “revelation.” The ads has been up for months and the logic is off. Imagine is Trump stopped advertising with everyone who reported on him. He’d have no one left now that he hates Fox News. Hahahaha. On a serious subject, blaming Ven and Wade for this doesn’t seem right. They were appointed to the board and not voted in and they haven’t been there during this whole crash. Strickland, Burden, Henderson and DON WEST are the ones we should be mad at. And if you know Joe Democko, you know he doesn’t want to be there anyway.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.